Leaving Preply or italki: what you have to replace, and why you may not want to leave at all

Updated November 17, 2026

Most tutors who start on Preply or italki reach the same question sooner or later: should I leave and go private? For most of us, the honest answer is not yet, and maybe not completely. Many tutors do best with both: a platform profile that keeps bringing in new students, and a private practice built from people who found them some other way.

This guide walks through the one rule you need to know, what happens if you break it, and the real pros and cons of staying, leaving or doing both. Everything about Preply and italki here comes from their own pages, which we read on 12 November 2026. Terms change, so check the current versions before you make a decision.

The rule: students you met on a platform stay there

This is the part that catches tutors out. If you met a student on Preply or italki, you can't move them to private lessons — even if they ask you to, and even if you'd both prefer it.

Both platforms say so in their terms. Preply's Terms of Service (section 3.4(f)) rule out teaching or taking payment from Preply students outside Preply, and italki's Terms of Service (section 12.2) do the same for italki. Neither platform lets you invite those students to your private practice, either. Preply's User Code of Conduct goes a step further and covers any Preply user, not only the students you met there.

If a student asks to move, the simplest reply is a friendly no: "I'd love to keep working with you, and we need to keep our lessons here on the platform."

As a tutor, the temptation to move off-platform is there, but you give up a lot by doing so. Besides breaking the terms and conditions, you'd have to handle everything yourself, including marketing, fees and payments. Many tutors want to focus on teaching, and leaving these jobs to the platform is an effective cost of doing business.

What happens if you take a platform student private

Here's what the terms allow each platform to do if it finds out:

  • Close your account. Both platforms can suspend or close a tutor's account for breaking the rule, straight away and without warning. italki also bans a suspended tutor from opening a new account.
  • Take your reviews with it. Your reviews live on your profile. If the platform closes the profile, the reviews can go with it, and nothing we read says you can take them with you.
  • Keep your money. Preply says it may keep any balance left in a closed account. italki holds your earnings as credits and can freeze or confiscate them, and it can also charge you the full fees it would have earned.
  • Hold you to the rule after you leave. Closing your account doesn't free the students. Both platforms say these restrictions continue after you stop using the service.

This is a summary of what the pages say, not legal advice. How a platform can enforce its terms depends on your country, so if it affects a real decision, ask someone qualified.

One more practical point, whatever you decide: don't leave money sitting in an account you've stopped using. Preply suspends an account after 180 days without a login, and the balance expires. italki's Payment Policy says credits expire after 12 months without activity. Withdraw your earnings before you step away.

What the platform does for you

The commission feels expensive, and it is. But it pays for real work, and when you go private, all of that work lands on your desk.

The jobOn the platformOn your own
Finding studentsThe platform brings students to you. Preply's commission page says this is where a large part of the commission goesYou find every student yourself
Booking and remindersStudents book your open times, and the platform sends the remindersYou set up a booking link and send your own reminders
PaymentPreply charges students in advance and renews automaticallyYou decide when you get paid, pay your provider's fee, and follow up when a payment fails
Late cancellationsPreply's 12-hour rule handles them for youYou write your own rule and agree it with each student
ReviewsPublic on your profileYou collect testimonials, with each student's permission
Lesson summariesPreply's Lesson Insights and italki's Smart Lessons can write them, for lessons booked on the platformYou write your own

What going private is worth: one student, in numbers

Preply keeps the whole fee for your trial lesson with each new student. After that, its commission page puts its share at 33% for new tutors, falling to 28% after 20 hours and down to 18% as your total hours grow. italki's commission page lists 0% on trials, 21% on single lessons, 15% to 19% on packages, and 30% on group classes.

One weekly student, in invented numbers

Sample

We made up these numbers for the example, so swap in your own rate. At $30 a lesson, one student who comes every week takes about 40 lessons a year, or $1,200 before anyone takes a cut.

Where the student booksThe platform keeps in a yearYou receive in a year
Preply, a new tutor (33%)$396$804
Preply, the lowest rate (18%)$216$984
italki, single lessons (21%)$252$948
italki, 20-lesson packages (15%)$180$1,020
Privately, a student you found yourself$0$1,200, less your payment provider's fee

On Preply, the platform also keeps the whole trial fee, so a $30 trial earns you $0. On italki, you keep the trial fee.

So in this example, one weekly student costs you somewhere between $180 and $396 a year on a platform. Whether that's worth it comes down to two questions. First, who found the student? If the platform did, that money is what you paid for the introduction. Second, what's your time worth? Divide that yearly cost by the hours you'd spend on booking, payments, cancellations and summaries for that student. If the answer is lower than your hourly rate, the platform is doing that work for less than you'd charge.

The pros and cons

Staying on a platform

Pros

  • New students find you, without any marketing on your part.
  • Booking, reminders, payments and cancellations are handled for you.
  • Reviews build up on your profile, where new students can read them.

Cons

  • The commission takes 15% to 33% of every lesson, plus the whole trial fee on Preply.
  • You don't own your profile, your reviews or your relationship with the student.
  • You can't move those students anywhere else, ever.

Going private

Pros

  • You keep the whole fee, less a small payment charge.
  • You set your own rates, cancellation rule, trial and packages.
  • Your student list belongs to you.

Cons

  • You have to find every student yourself, and that takes time.
  • You take on the admin: booking, invoices, failed payments and cancellations.
  • Your income dips while you build the list, because you can't bring platform students with you.

The middle path: do both

For most tutors, the best answer is to keep both going. Your platform profile brings in new students, and your private practice grows from people who know you. That way, your private list grows while platform lessons still pay the bills, instead of after you've emptied your week.

Keep the two separate, though. italki's Teacher Policy (section 1.2) bans contact details and ads for other teaching in your lesson descriptions, and Preply's Terms (section 27) ban using the platform to promote another business. Your profile can't mention your private practice.

If your week fills up, Preply lets you hide your profile so it drops out of search while your current students can still book. You can show it again later. Deleting a profile is permanent, so hiding it is the safer step. The italki pages we read don't mention hiding a profile.

Leaving completely can still be the right move — for example, when nearly all your hours are already with people who found you elsewhere. Run the numbers with your own figures first, and leave platform students out of the private column.

Where private students come from

A private student is someone who found you somewhere other than a platform. Check that's true of each person before you offer a private lesson. Three good places to start:

  • People who knew you before any platform. Former colleagues, people from a field you worked in before teaching (handy for Business English), and learners from a school where you taught, if your contract there allows it.
  • People your private students send you. After a good lesson, ask each private student once for one name: someone who needs English for the same reasons they do. A person they introduce found you through them, not through a marketplace.
  • Your own page. Add one line to your own website, or to a professional profile outside the platforms, saying that you teach English privately and how to reach you. Keep it off your Preply and italki profiles.

Where Sumna fits

Sumna is for the students you teach privately, never for platform lessons. For a student who found you elsewhere, it turns your recording or transcript into a class summary that builds on that student's earlier summaries. Nothing goes out until you've checked it and sent it under your own name.

Read five weeks of summaries for one fictional student. No account needed.

See the five-week sample
  • Your transcripts stay in your account. You can delete them, or a whole student record, at any time. They are not used to train models.
  • To start: your email, the link we send, then a lesson transcript.
  • Free: 10 summaries to start, then 3 a month. No card, no time limit. Entry is $19 a month for 30, about 7 lessons a week. Expert is $37 for 60, about 14.

Sources